So, for all the parents out there that commented here, Instagram and on Facebook about having a similar issue, I wanted to let you know how it turned out for us. Because she wanted to go to practice and games but just didn't want to actually go IN and play, we just stuck with it. I would have taken her to every game and practice of the season and sat on the sidelines with her, as long as she wanted to go. Thankfully she finally warmed up to it and started playing more and more each game. It makes me feel like we made the right decision by continuing to take her and I'm so thankful for that.
Keep on, keepin on, amirite? ;)